Overripe Bananas? Blow Off Banana Bread – You Got Pudding Fixins!

After decades of making banana bread with over-the-hill bananas I pondered on an easy pudding recipe. Wowzer, this is a new path to dessert bliss!

INGREDIENTS: Plantains, cousin to bananas, are equally delicious. If not using coconut milk, choose a thick alternate: I use oat milk or half n half. This recipe is developed using agar or agar-agar, a seaweed derived thickener. It is easily found at Asian or international markets. You might exchange agar for gelatin, but I have not tried that at this point.

• bananas – 2, very ripe, [1 1/2 cups], chopped [or plantains]
• coconut milk – 1/2 cup or more [or other thick plant milk] or [half n half]
• rice vinegar – 1 TBS
• butter – 2 TBS
• salt – pinch
• sugar – 3+ TBS [or brown sugar]
• corn starch – 3 TBS
• nutmeg – 1/4 tsp [or 1/8 tsp allspice]
• rum – 2 TBS [optional]
• vanilla – 1 tsp

GARNISH

• nuts – chopped for garnish [walnuts are great]
• Greek yogurt or whipped cream for garnish
• banana slices

INSTRUCTIONS: If you have extra bananas, plan on slicing for garnish

1. Place 1-1/2 cups of chopped bananas in a 2 cup measuring cup
2. Add liquid of choice to fill to the 2 cup mark
3. Add the vinegar
4. Meanwhile, brown the butter over medium-low heat in a 2 quart pot. Watch and stir so as not to burn. When butter solids begin to brown and gives off a nutty scent, remove pot from heat [the pureed banana will be added next]
5. Puree the banana, milk, and vinegar along with the remaining ingredients
6. Add the banana puree to the brown butter and under medium-low heat bring to a bare simmer
7. When thick bubbles appear, stir continually for a minute then remove from heat
8. Pour into a serving bowl or individual dishes
9. Slice up extra bananas and decorate the pudding(s)
10. Cool to room temperature then refrigerate for at least 3-4 hours before serving
11. Top with yogurt or whipped cream, and nuts

The color of the pudding will darken over time

There are a great selection of Puddins here

© 2021-2025 Recipe by B. Hettig